After job spikes during the pandemic, tech companies are now laying off staff in layoffs that sometimes involve thousands of employees. Layoffs may be necessary to boost lower profit margins, but advocates of diversity in the tech sector say job cuts can disproportionately affect underrepresented groups. I am concerned.
According to Layoffs.fyi, 152,542 employees at 993 global tech companies were laid off in 2022, according to an online tracker that monitors job losses in the tech sector.
While the COVID-19 pandemic has hit industries such as events and hospitality hard economically, organizations operating in the technology sector are working to meet the perceived needs of customers who have become completely dependent on technology. We experienced a period of overgrowth in which we expanded rapidly.
However, every boom is usually followed by a recession, and in the fourth quarter of 2022, big tech companies faced a drop in revenue. [let’s be specific] and impending recession. As a result, Twitter’s new owner Elon Musk cut its social media platform’s workforce in half, Meta announced 11,000 job cuts, and Amazon laid off 20,000 employees, according to a report. , lists some of the layoffs the tech industry has seen this year.
Those affected will always find unemployment unfair, but in an industry that continues to be dominated by men, employees from minority backgrounds are likely to bear the brunt of layoffs.
Technology companies are more likely to employ women and minorities in many non-tech departments, including business development, customer success, communications, and marketing. As a result, when it comes to headcount reductions, individuals in these roles are more likely to face layoffs because they are seen as less important to the business than those who develop or maintain the product.
But recent events suggest that underrepresented employees are disproportionately affected, even in tech teams that are even less represented by women and minorities. For example, two of her women, who lost their jobs on Twitter, filed a lawsuit, claiming that the company was unfairly targeting female employees.
In the lawsuit, which accuses the company of violating federal and California laws against sex discrimination in the workplace, Twitter fired 57% of its female workers compared to 47% of its male workers. said. Regarding engineering roles, the lawsuit claims 63% of women lost their jobs compared to 48% of men.
Issues facing minority employees
The tech industry is familiar with the concept of boom-bust cycles, but job security is not always guaranteed and the challenges associated with working in an often rewarding sector are Not everyone can afford it. chance. [I tweaked this because I thought this is what you meant.]
The impact of losing a job is always difficult, but industry instability can also pose challenges for women who may have to consider things such as maternity leave, or who may have to consider caregiving responsibilities when looking for a job. Hywel Carver said the possibility of becoming an unattractive one. , Deep His Coaching for Developers His platform, he is the CEO and co-founder of Skiller Whale.
Even if tech team employees are laid off, they are unlikely to struggle to find open positions — but according to a November 2021 study by Skillsoft, about 4 IT decision makers worldwide Three-thirds claim they face significant skills gaps across the tech sector — it is more difficult for minority employees to get jobs at companies with good working conditions.
A study published in the MIT Sloan Management Review earlier this year found that a toxic company culture was the strongest predictor of employee turnover and was 10 times more important than compensation in predicting turnover. rice field. Research shows that key factors contributing to toxic cultures include failure to promote diversity, equity and inclusion. Workers feel neglected. unethical behavior.
Meri Williams, CTO of business payments company Pleo and adviser to technical skills education firm Skiller Whale, said that for minority employees, if they leave and join a new place, the risks associated with finding a new job are high. He said it could be much bigger. It’s like stepping out of a frying pan and into a fire.
“I know a lot of women, people of color, LGBTQ+ people. We are thinking carefully,” Williams said.
Additionally, Ingrid B Laman, vice president of advisory for Gartner’s HR practice, said companies have increased investment and commitment to DE&I (diversity, equity, and inclusion) programs in recent years. , pointed out that many employees are afraid of economic pressure. The job cuts, combined with growing backlash against the DEI’s efforts, will derail these efforts as budget cuts are made and key her members of staff move.
“A recent Gartner study found that underrepresented groups, such as racially and ethnically diverse employees, had lower career satisfaction, higher voluntary turnover, and higher rates of employee turnover than the majority group. It has become clear that many organizations are failing to reap the performance impact of a highly diverse and inclusive work environment.”
Additionally, as companies seek to minimize headcount, many business leaders are returning to pre-pandemic ways of working in a misguided attempt to boost productivity. There’s no evidence that working face-to-face makes teams more productive, but companies such as Twitter and Apple have introduced policies requiring employees to be physically in the office for the majority of her week. doing.
In December 2021, Deloitte reported that women’s unemployment was minimized during the pandemic due to the inherently flexible nature of the tech industry and its ability to rapidly transition to remote work. Flexibility was a priority for her, 53% of UK working-age women, compared to only 38% of men. Despite this, both on Twitter and Tesla, owner Elon Musk has publicly declared that he will fire any employees who do not return to the office.
Williams argued that forcing everyone back into the office would likely be particularly hurtful to underrepresented groups of employees.
“I think that some of the layoffs that have been implemented, and especially the fact that people have been forced back into the office, have had a very negative impact on DE&I,” Williams said. “I don’t think that’s a good thing when you think about someone who has responsibilities to look after and is forced to return to an office that is usually in a very busy city and has a long commute.”
“I think it’s a terrible strategy if you care about having a diverse mix of people on your team,” they said.
How can companies do better?
Layoffs dominated the story later this year, but there’s evidence that the big resignations aren’t over yet. Online job site Hired has found that attracting, hiring and retaining top talent has proven difficult. Employee burnout is cited as a major challenge, due to rapid changes in the employment environment and fears of mass layoffs and hiring freezes.
For companies that have not yet announced layoffs, before making any decisions, organizations should factor DE&I into their layoff decisions, Laman said.
“For example, companies must maintain a core of DE&I champions within their teams, ensure that layoff discussions are free of unconscious bias, and that representatives across the business are not inadvertently affected by these layoffs. ‘ she said.
But Williams argued that there is plenty of evidence to suggest that they are doing pattern matching when trying to find possibilities. At the level of making decisions about who stays and who leaves, they may not understand or recognize the potential for some people to look or be very different from themselves.
Carver agrees, saying that being a good manager is not the same as being a good technologist, and people often get promoted despite lacking the necessary management skills.
“I don’t think all companies get it right if they are going to evaluate people who are in the bottom 10% in terms of performance and therefore should be fired,” he said. rice field. “I think the people who hurt the most when they make the wrong decisions are the people who are unconsciously biased. They are often an underrepresented group. It is.”
Job losses may be inevitable in the business world, but job cuts at some tech companies have been particularly severe this year. But Tony Lysak, Founder and CEO of The Software Institute, doesn’t believe the change will completely undermine the organization’s long-standing commitment to diversity.
“I think the corporate demand for diversity is very strong and the industry is actually very well positioned.” More women, minorities and disadvantaged people are moving forward in the talent pipeline.
“In the UK, for example, government agencies and major organizations are looking to northern towns such as Telford, Manchester and Newcastle to build centers of excellence and target local disadvantaged workers,” he said. I was.
As most countries deepen during this time of economic struggle, companies are engaging in candid dialogue, clarifying the business, talent and reputational risks of underinvesting in DE&I and criticizing these initiatives as impractical. While making sure they are seen, they need to see executive commitment to the DE&I strategy, Laman said. Negotiable.
“To fully embed DEI into their business, organizations need to enable executives to set their own DEI targets, hold them accountable, and embed DEI into their business practices,” she said. rice field.
Copyright © 2023 IDG Communications, Inc.
