What the U.S. TikTok ban would mean for advocates demanding a say

A culmination of dozens of national security and data privacy hearings on the congressional floor saw lawmakers meet and debate this week The fate of the popular app TikTokfacing potential government bansHowever, unlike regular public hearings, debate defense does more than just drive data and precedent. brought to life by the creators themselves(opens in new tab)on the ground in Washington, DC, telling stories, creating content, and advocating: We use this app and we want your opinion.

Wednesday, online after a TikTok press conference and meeting with representatives. @grace_africa(opens in new tab), posted a video of himself(opens in new tab) Drive through the Capitol Rotunda and tune in to singer Lizzie McAlpine’s popular TikTok clip of “Ceilings.” “But it’s not real! And you don’t exist!” the song roared on her tour of historic landmarks.

Meanwhile, Aidan Kohn-Murphy — Founder of TikTok-based non-profit youth advocacy group @GenZForChange(opens in new tab) – was I filmed myself as the first person to shout “Ikemen!”(opens in new tab) in the dome room.

Reply to Kohn-Murphy’s video, User Yay(opens in new tab) “Nothing will convince lawmakers to ban TikTok more than meeting with actual TikTok content creators.”

“There are things about TikTok influencers that are very difficult for my brain to calculate. [sic] We shot a romantic video of the Houses of Parliament when I had a minor breakdown on one of the benches she passed by.” murmured(opens in new tab) Daily Beast Political reporter Ursula Perano sharing Amaku’s TikTok.

Soundtracked by the latest TikTok bedroom pop hits, there’s certainly humor in the juxtaposition of creators running through the rotunda. dance on the roof of a building(opens in new tab) Legislators decide the fate of apps, but many of their creators are passionate about protecting the communities they form there.

For the mental health advocates and creators of TikTok, the issue isn’t one of geopolitical debate Jorge Alvarez(opens in new tab) explained. “This is more pressing for people, both financially and economically. It is a very important organizing tool. At this point, I hope they can recognize that there were people here, trying to put their face to this.”

And of course, it’s their nature to post online. Influencers influence, creatives create, advocates advocate.

It’s important that it’s not super-famous creators banging pot on the front lawn of the White House. It’s successfully transitioned to real-world money-making opportunities and Hollywood gigs. Tiffany Yu(opens in new tab), Deedle Kelly(opens in new tab)and even Amak and Corn Murphy represent another part of the app that focuses on advocacy, education, and small-scale community building.

This group of creators at risk claims to be a free platform for marginalized groups to share new perspectives and knowledge, gain confidence in their individual advocacy, and build financial self-sufficiency. I’m here.

Yu, a disability advocate who posts videos about disability. anti-disability(opens in new tab) and Career Advice for People with Disabilities(opens in new tab)explained the stakes of the disabled community on TikTok. “People with disabilities are some of the most socially isolated and socially excluded groups. Infrastructure, or other barriers, keep us out and lonely,” she said.

While Yu has spent the last 25 years of his life battling isolation and grief related to sudden-onset disability, dedicated to bridging these gaps through grassroots activism and non-profit advocacy, TikTok is helping to reach him. It has provided a much broader range of tools. Other people like her. She also pioneered new ways for creators with disabilities to support themselves in the community.

“We need advocacy and financial self-sufficiency. I think for a long time they felt mutually exclusive,” Yu told Mashable. “Being a creator for me is a possibility. Others haven’t given us opportunities, so we’re going to make our own.”

Yu said people from marginalized groups also need social connections to survive, and the internet has stepped in to provide them. The empathetic conversation and sense of intimacy on the app echoed in DC’s conversations with his TikTok creator. And for video-based communities like TikTok, he argues that the ability to organize and advocate like in the app doesn’t really exist elsewhere. Alvarez said of his launch of TikTok in 2021, “It was the easiest app to get started with. was,” he explained.

“This has been a very important tool in terms of amplifying my voice. Take the National Stage at the White House(opens in new tab)I have the awareness and the resources to accept my advocacy and be able to do something,” Alvarez said.

Kelly, a 6th grade math teacher, said that educational videos have exploded in popularity among students and parents, allowing them to use the TikTok platform to partner with outside organizations they otherwise would not have had access to. say. She uses her children’s and school’s resources, as well as other educators, to make up for the scarce funds. “TikTok is another way to get your voice out even further,” Kelly said. “There are big companies that reach out to content creators. It’s a huge platform.”

Along with fellow creators, Kelly spoke directly to delegates like newly elected Gen Z Congressman Maxwell Frost about the impact TikTok has had on their relationships with students and other education-focused creators. “We are all trying to use TikTok as a resource to educate, not just in our classrooms.”

Meanwhile, the broader political dialogue is examining corporate misconduct and global data privacy issues related to national political attitudes toward TikTok ownership. Speaking directly with CEO Shou Zi Chew, Rep. Bob Latta (R-OH5) summed up the sentiments of many delegates, stating: Based on the established relationship between your company and the Chinese Communist Party, it is impossible to conclude that this video is any different from the type of propaganda the Chinese Communist Party claims to impose on Chinese companies. to its citizens. ”

In addition to concerns about the safety and data security of young people unprotected by “big tech,” other representatives said: Inaccurate and Harmful Medical Informationgraphic content, and Social Media in Mental and Emotional HealthAll of this has increased the wariness of apps from older generations and industry leaders.

However, many online point to the kind of hypocrisy in the enthusiasm shown by congressional leaders to ban the app, specifically pointing to similar data privacy concerns on other platforms, points to the slow move by the Biden administration to codify other protections for youth.For people of color. “These people just aren’t on TikTok,” Alvarez said. “They don’t really understand what an app is beyond just entertainment.”

Tweet may have been deleted
(opens in new tab)
(opens in new tab)

Tweet may have been deleted
(opens in new tab)
(opens in new tab)

Tweet may have been deleted
(opens in new tab)
(opens in new tab)

Several, Includes parent TikTok representatives(opens in new tab)also, this week’s comment feels like it’s part of an underlying xenophobia toward China’s tech leaders and app users. It’s just been done. It’s just evolved,” Amak told Mashable. Because it’s blatant.”

Amaku also explained to Mashable his motivation for posting the rotunda clip during the week’s proceedings. “I used that song specifically because it talks about removing the joy that was once in someone’s life. TikTok was a dream for many people.” He explained the irony of being toured based on the conquest of institutions, non-white, non-male bodies.

“Yes, it was I who built the United States of America, surrounded by all these leaders, but not using the most moral and virtuous route,” she said. , they control our free speech. They still control our progress.”

Amaku explained that he joined DC’s group to defend that young people using TikTok are no longer tolerating unfair practices and to challenge representatives who don’t understand the app. bottom. She said TikTok became a place of encouragement for “unpopular” children who faced racist and xenophobic bullying because of their Nigerian-American first-generation identities. says there is. “TikTok is an expression of that, about not being bound by social norms — about letting creativity flourish — and that’s why I think it’s my safe haven.”

After Thursday’s hearing, TikTok President Brooke Oberwetter released a statement reflecting on the day: “Shou was ready to answer questions from Congress, but unfortunately that day was a political grandstand. and did not acknowledge a real solution already underway through Project Texas or Project Texas to productively address the industry-wide problem of youth safety. No: The First Amendment Impact of Banning 5 Million Business Lives on TikTok and the Platform Beloved by 150 Million Americans.”

Government representatives themselves are using TikTok as a way to reach young voices and promote their own initiatives, and as the entertainment and commercial industries turn the app into a generator of content and capital, people are also getting basic It has become dependent on the app for its purpose. , human necessities—for better or worse.

Yu says he’s thinking about the second-degree implications of the ban beyond the decision made after hearings this week.

“Will people continue to have a support system they can rely on? Is there a place to learn outside the echo chamber? Are you sure there is a transition plan available for those financially dependent on creating content? We hope that these decisions are made with caution in the light of our community and what we have gained.”

Want more news about advocacy and digital culture? Delivered straight to your inbox? Sign up Mashable’s Top Stories Newsletter today.